Setting the Standard for Women in Firearms | Training. Insights. Intelligence.

Revolvers and Cartridge Types: Rimmed vs. Rimless

When you look at a revolver, the cylinder is probably the first thing that catches your attention. With a semi-automatic pistol, it’s the slide. You may notice the hammer, trigger, sights, or grip before you ever think about the ammunition.

But take a closer look at the cartridges and you’ll notice another difference, one that’s easy to miss until you know what you’re looking for. Look at the base of the cartridge. Does the rim extend beyond the case? Or does it stay the same diameter as the case?

That small difference is what we mean when we describe ammunition as rimmed or rimless. And while the difference may seem minor, it plays an important role in how the cartridge is positioned and extracted from the firearm.

The Difference in Design

On a rimmed cartridge, the rim extends beyond the diameter of the case. This projecting rim helps position the cartridge in the revolver’s cylinder and gives the extractor a surface to push against when the fired case is removed.

On a rimless cartridge, the rim stays within the diameter of the case. Just forward of the rim, you will typically see an extractor groove. The firearm’s extractor engages this groove when removing the cartridge from the chamber.

Once you know what to look for, the difference is easy to see.

Rimmed Cartridges

Rimmed cartridges are commonly used in revolvers. Each cartridge sits in its own chamber in the cylinder, and the rim helps establish its position.

This relates to headspace, which refers to how far the cartridge sits in the chamber. Proper headspace is important for safe and reliable firearm operation.

Common rimmed handgun cartridges include:

  • .38 Special
  • .357 Magnum
  • .44 Magnum

Rimless Cartridges

Rimless cartridges are commonly used in semi-automatic pistols. Their design works with the feeding and extraction systems found in these firearms and allows cartridges to be arranged efficiently in a magazine.

Common examples include:

  • 9mm
  • .40 S&W
  • .45 ACP
  • 10mm

The term rimless can be confusing at first. The cartridge still has a rim. It simply does not extend beyond the diameter of the case. The extractor groove near the base gives the firearm’s extractor a surface to engage.

rimless v rimmed

This illustration shows the difference between rimmed and rimless cartridge designs. Courtesy of Simply About Guns.

IMG_20150212_142615-2

This photo compares a Winchester 9mm on the left with a Train and Defend .38 on the right.

How the Design Affects Function

The difference in cartridge design makes more sense when you consider how the firearms operate.

In a revolver, cartridges are loaded directly into the cylinder. The rim helps keep each cartridge in the correct position. When the cylinder is opened, the extractor pushes against the rims to remove the fired cases.

In a semi-automatic pistol, cartridges are fed from the magazine into the chamber. When the action cycles, the extractor engages the groove near the base of the case and removes the fired cartridge.

The cartridge and firearm are designed to work together. The shape of the cartridge helps support the way the firearm loads, fires, and extracts ammunition.

Rimless Cartridges in Some Revolvers

Rimmed cartridges are common in revolvers, but some revolvers are designed to use rimless cartridges. In these firearms, moon clips can be used to hold the cartridges together and position them in the cylinder.

The moon clip also gives the revolver’s extractor a surface to push against when removing the cartridges.

A full-moon clip holds a complete cylinder’s worth of ammunition. A half-moon clip holds a portion of the cylinder’s ammunition.

Moon clips are one example of how firearm design can accommodate different cartridge designs.

Check Your Firearm Before Loading

Knowing the difference between rimmed and rimless cartridges is helpful, but it does not tell you which ammunition to use in your firearm.

Before loading, look for the caliber marking on the firearm itself. Depending on the firearm, you may find it on the barrel, frame, slide, or another visible part of the firearm. The marking will usually include a number or caliber designation, such as 9mm, .38 Special, or .45 ACP.

Make sure the ammunition you are using matches the caliber specified for your firearm.

If you cannot find the marking or you are unsure whether your ammunition is correct, stop and ask a qualified firearms instructor or another knowledgeable professional.

Ammunition is one place where guessing is never worth it.

What to Remember

The easiest way to tell the difference between a rimmed and rimless cartridge is to look at the base.

A rimmed cartridge has a rim that extends beyond the diameter of the case. A rimless cartridge has a rim that stays within the diameter of the case.

Rimmed cartridges are commonly used in revolvers, while rimless cartridges are commonly used in semi-automatic pistols. There are exceptions, such as revolvers designed to use rimless cartridges with moon clips.

Learning to recognize the difference is one small step toward understanding how ammunition and firearms work together. And when it comes to choosing ammunition, always start with the firearm and its markings rather than trying to identify the correct cartridge by appearance alone.

Leave a Reply

Keep Learning

Here are a few more articles that we think you’ll enjoy.

Articles & Videos

Categories

Search Topics

Skillsets